Skip to content Skip to footer

Navigating the Controversy: The Shift from N95 to Surgical Masks in Healthcare Settings

Our latest infographic serves as an instrument of knowledge for nurse leaders aiming to prioritize and address 22 of the most crucial challenges that the healthcare workforce is currently facing. As part of our ongoing promise to assist healthcare professionals, we continue to offer a service center where we tackle any inquiries related to membership, research, and even pressing healthcare issues. The size of the question is of no consequence; we are committed to providing valuable assistance on any front.

In other developments, the Center for Disease Control’s Healthcare Infection Control Practices Advisory Committee (HICPAC) is contemplating upgrading its infection control protocols in hospitals that were last revised in 2007. Key among revisions, the assertion that surgical face masks could replace the N95 masks in certain healthcare settings. Such a move has sparked anxiety among some health experts who perceive this would place both patients and healthcare providers in a precarious position. These concerns are echoed in a report by Amy Maxmen for KFF Health News.

According to the June draft report by HICPAC, several studies seemingly found no distinction in infection rates within healthcare settings, regardless of whether healthcare providers wore N95 or surgical masks. Despite acknowledging shortcomings in the research methodology, the committee maintained its position. In their view, surgical masks offered adequate protection against a range of viruses categorized as ‘common, endemic,’ which manifest over short distances and against which communities would have developed some degree of immunity.
However, the categorization of viruses into tiers and the recommendation on the type of mask required for each has sparked debates, particularly with respect to how COVID-19 falls into this system. Health experts have found it particularly troubling, warning that it could put vulnerable patients at risk. They argue that proven measures such as the use of N95 masks, enhanced ventilation and air-purifying technology should remain in place to lower transmission rates.

Regarding the effectiveness of mask types, studies show conflicting results. A 2022 CDC report found N95 masks to have a higher protective benefit against COVID-19 when compared to surgical and cloth masks. Moreover, a 2017 clinical trial noted N95 masks as significantly more protective against influenza than surgical masks. These findings align with The Royal Society of the United Kingdom’s evaluation that globally, N95 masks were considerably more effective against COVID-19 in healthcare settings than surgical masks.

The unveiling of this potentially new CDC guidance previously scheduled for August 2022 was postponed till November following resounding concerns raised by health professionals. The apprehension, particularly seen among experts, is that a downgrade of mask standards to surgical masks could put both patients and healthcare providers in harm’s way, further worsening the rising COVID-19 cases across the United States.

Besides the recommended downgrading of mask standards, healthcare experts are also troubled by the categorizations proposed by the committee. They argue that the spread potential of a pathogen isn’t mitigated by its prevalence. The categorization proposed by the committee is seen to oversimplify the complex behavior of infectious aerosols which can spread far and wide, regardless of confinement measures. A solution suggested by some includes improving mask design and testing, rather than abandoning N95 masks altogether.

All things considered, the new guidelines have elicited valid concerns amid the healthcare community. There’s a looming fear that the standards could render hospitals less secure. It is vital, therefore, that the CDC considers these concerns and ensures that any guideline it develops is all-encompassing, with a keen focus on the safety of patients, visitors, and healthcare workers.


Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Be the first to know the latest updates

[yikes-mailchimp form="1"]