Skip to content Skip to footer

Addressing the Decline in Patient Safety Ratings in South Florida Hospitals: The Role of Infection Prevention

The importance of patient safety in South Florida hospitals has come under scrutiny following the latest ratings release from the Leapfrog Group. According to the leading nonprofit watchdog, many hospitals in the region have seen a significant dip in their safety ratings compared to previous years. The group’s comprehensive report from fall 2023 revealed diminished scores for six hospitals between Jupiter and Key Biscayne, each receiving a dismal ‘D’ grade for patient safety. These hospitals include Jackson South in Miami, North Shore Medical Center in Miami, HCA Florida Northwest Hospital in Margate, Florida Medical Center in Fort Lauderdale, Baptist Health Boca Regional Hospital, and HCA Florida JFK Hospital in Atlantis. With each of these establishments previously holding a ‘C’ rating a year prior, this represents a concerning downward trend.

A broader ‘Bs and Cs’ rating was received by the majority of the other 33 South Florida hospitals when assessed for medical errors, injuries sustained during hospital stays, and incidences of in-patient infections. However, there were shining examples of patient safety excellence, with five hospitals in the tri-county region managing to secure an ‘A’ rating. These were Baptist Health Doctors Hospital in Coral Gables, Baptist Health Homestead Hospital, HCA Florida Westside Hospital in Plantation, Memorial Hospital Miramar, and Jupiter Medical Center in Palm Beach County.

Leapfrog not only evaluates general patient safety concerns like medical errors and injuries but also specifically considers infection measures. It assesses the prevalence of Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) cases, central line infections, and urinary tract infections occurring in hospitalized patients. In addition to these variables, the ratings reflect the effectiveness of communication about medicines and the responsiveness of hospital staff.

Over the last two years, results suggest a disturbing downward trend in patient safety scores, with the biggest decreases observed in workforce-shortage-stricken regions, including Florida. The diminished ratings are linked to workforce shortages, affecting nurses’ availability to answer call buttons promptly and provide quality patient care. Hospitals have been further affected by a decline in their scores for areas such as nursing and doctor communication and discharge information. Now, as the trend continues, healthcare professionals and hospital CEOs will need to take robust action to reverse it.

Workforce shortages pose a national concern and inevitably hinder hospitals’ ability to deliver optimal care. Despite these challenges, Steven Ullmann, director of the Center for Health Management and Policy at the University of Miami, emphasizes the feasibility of processes to enhance patient safety outcomes. Nonetheless, these improvement initiatives whose goal would be to prevent infections, minimize medical errors, and improve staff responsiveness must be instituted at all levels. Additionally, Ullmann advises patients to conduct thorough research on hospitals’ operations, safety measures, and infection control policies before choosing a healthcare provider.

Leapfrog’s patient safety grades serve as an invaluable tool for hospitals to measure and enhance their quality controls, especially noted in the aftermath of the pandemic. As the only ratings program focusing on the prevention of medical errors and patient harm, Leapfrog allows hospitals to understand where improvements are required and take steps towards enhanced patient safety.


Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Be the first to know the latest updates

[yikes-mailchimp form="1"]